I actually don't think this is an easy choice myself, so I will give an opt out answer of Ian 'Evans' Evatt as the manager instead!
1 - Doyle with his goals
2 -Santos and Baptiste at the back
3 - Lee and MJ the January signings turned or season completely around.
4 - Crellin for being so bad (no harm meant, just that it clearly wasn't his time yet) that forced Gilks to play in goal instead.
Anybody brave enough to go for one of the four and with reasobs why?